RE/MAX Select · Kyle R. Kerwin, REALTOR®, Sales Associate · NJ License #2550092

RE/MAX SelectKyle Kerwin, REALTOR®

Sussex County, NJ

Buying and Selling a Home in Stillwater Township, NJ

Stillwater Township is lake country west of Newton — Swartswood Lake and Swartswood State Park, Paulins Kill Lake, Fairview Lake and Crandon Lakes.

Stillwater Township at a glance

Stillwater Township is home to Swartswood State Park, established in 1914 and described as New Jersey's first state park, with Swartswood Lake at its center. Paulins Kill Lake was created in the 1920s by damming the Paulins Kill. Other lakes include Fairview Lake, Catfish Pond and Lake Kathryn, and Crandon Lakes is shared with Hampton. County Route 521 is the main road; no interstate, U.S. or state highways cross the township.

What the housing is like in Stillwater Township

  • Lake homes on Swartswood Lake, Paulins Kill Lake, Fairview Lake and Crandon Lakes.
  • Rural single-family homes on wells and septic.
  • Farms and acreage in the valley.

What buyers should check in Stillwater Township

  1. Lake association rules. Each lake community has its own documents, dues and access rules.
  2. Wells and septic. Plan for the required well test and a septic inspection.
  3. Commuting. With no state highways in town, check your real drive to Route 206, Route 15 or I-80.
  4. Property taxes. Look at the actual tax bill for the house, not an average, and compare Stillwater Township's rate using the state's municipal tax data.
  5. Town certificates. New Jersey requires a smoke alarm, carbon monoxide alarm and fire extinguisher certificate at a change of occupancy; ask the town about any added resale inspections.

Selling a home in Stillwater Township

Stillwater's lakes draw year-round and seasonal buyers. Lake access, system condition and winter usability drive value.

Want to know what homes like yours in Stillwater Township have actually sold for? Get a free home valuation, or search homes for sale if you're buying.

A note on fair housing

I describe homes, land and places — not who lives where. For school information, I point you to official sources so you can decide for yourself.

Local questions

Stillwater Township real estate FAQs

Is Swartswood State Park in Stillwater?

Yes. Swartswood State Park, established in 1914, is in Stillwater Township, with Swartswood Lake and Little Swartswood Lake.

Is Stillwater Township in the New Jersey Highlands?

No. Stillwater Township isn't on the NJ Highlands Council's list of Sussex County Highlands municipalities. Local zoning, wetlands and flood rules still apply.

What school district serves Stillwater Township?

Stillwater Township School District (PreK–6); grades 7–12 attend Kittatinny Regional High School.

Is there a train station in Stillwater Township?

No. Stillwater Township doesn't have an NJ Transit rail station, so most residents drive. The main roads are county Route 521 (no interstate, U.S. or state highways).

What is the property tax rate in Stillwater Township?

Rates change every year and vary by municipality. Check the NJ Division of Taxation's general and effective tax rates, and always look at the actual tax bill for the home you're considering.

How much is my Stillwater Township home worth?

Online estimates struggle in North Jersey because lot size, water and sewer type, lake access and condition vary so much. A comparative market analysis using hand-picked recent sales is far more reliable — I'll prepare one for free.

Related guides

Helpful reading for Stillwater Township buyers and sellers

Sources and further reading

  1. Stillwater Township, New Jersey — Wikipedia (general reference)
  2. Sussex County Highlands municipalities — NJ Highlands Council
  3. Statistical Information (general and effective tax rates) — NJ Division of Taxation
  4. Private Well Testing Act rule, N.J.A.C. 7:9E-2.1 — New Jersey Administrative Code
  5. FEMA Flood Map Service Center — FEMA

Buying, selling, or still figuring it out?

A short conversation with someone who knows these towns can save you months and money.

CallTextHome Value